Andrew Kliman - Reclaiming Marx's Capital Contents Preface Note Chapter 1 - Introduction: The Question of Internal Inconsistency 1.1 The Lion and the Statue 1.2 What This Book Is (and Isn’t) About 1.3 The Importance of the Internal Inconsistency Question 1.4 The Influence of the Internal Inconsistency Allegations 1.5 Why This Particular Book? 1.6 Whig History, Pluralism, and Dogmatism 1.6.1 Whiggism vs. Pluralism 1.6.2 The Most Effective Whiggish Strategy 1.6.3 “Only One Path” Forward? 1.7 Outline of Subsequent Chapters Notes Chapter 2 - Marx’s Value Theory and Contending Interpretations 2.1 Marx’s Value Theory 2.1.1 Commodity Production 2.1.2 Determination of Value by Labor-Time 2.1.3 Value Transferred and New Value Added 2.1.4 Productivity and Value Creation 2.1.5 Constant Capital, Variable Capital, and Surplus-Value 2.1.6 The Origin of Surplus-Value 2.1.7 Two Distinctions between Value and Price 2.1.8 The Monetary Expression of Labor-Time (MELT) 2.1.9 “Value” and “Price” Rates of Profit 2.1.10 The Tendency of Profit Rates to Equalize 2.1.11 Average Profit and Price of Production 2.1.12 The Tendential Fall In the Rate of Profit 2.1.13 The Rising Rate of Surplus-Value and Its Limited Effect 2.1.14 The Meaning of “Tendential Fall" 2.2 Contending Interpretations 2.2.1 Dual-system Interpretations 2.2.2 Single-system Interpretations 2.2.3 Simultaneous vs. Temporal Valuation 2.2.4 Simultaneism and Physicalism 2.2.5 The “Value-Form” Paradigm Notes Chapter 3 - A Brief History of the Controversy 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Dmitriev’s Laborless Theory of Value 3.3 The Falling Rate of Profit Controversy 3.4 Origins of the “Transformation Problem" 3.5 Marxian Economics as General Equilibrium Theory 3.6 The Master’s Tools 3.7 The Transformation of Physical Quantities into Values and Prices 3.8 Reinterpreting Marx Notes Chapter 4 - Making Marx Make Sense: On Interpretive Method 4.1 Introduction 4.2 How Not to Interpret 4.3 The Meaning and Interpretation of Analytical Arguments 4.4 Knowing What an Author Meant 4.5 The Criterion of Coherence 4.6 Stigler’s “Principle of Scientific Exegesis" 4.7 Barkai and Hollander on the PSE 4.8 In Defense of the Criterion of Coherence and the PSE 4.9 Critics' Responses Notes Chapter 5 - Simultaneism, Physicalism, and the Law of Value 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Definitions 5.3 Simultaneous Valuation vs. the Law of Value 5.4 Simultaneous Valuation and the Redundancy of Value 5.5 Simultaneous Valuation and Negative Values 5.6 Accumulation for the Sake of Non-Accumulation 5.7 A Simple Example Notes Chapter 6 - Was Marx a Simultaneist? 6.1 Introduction 6.2 What Remains to be Shown? 6.3 The Static Equilibrium vs. the Average Rate of Profit 6.4 The Replacement-Cost Interpretation 6.4.1 Conceptual Distinctions 6.4.2 Evidence of Simultaneous Valuation in Marx’s Work? 6.4.3 Discontinuing Evidence 6.4.4 Marx’s Examples of Value Determination 6.4.5 Summary 6.5 One System or Two? Notes Chapter 7 - The Falling Rate of Profit Controversy 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Why the Okishio Theorem Has Not Been Proved 7.2.1 Marx’s Equilibrium Rate of Profit 7.2.2 The Okishio Theorem’s Equilibrium Rate of Profit 7.2.3 Simultaneist Critiques of the Okishio Theorem 7.3 Physical Determination of Profitability: Obvious or Implausible? 7.3.1 A Simple Example 7.3.2 The Simultaneist Value/Price Rate of Profit 7.3.3 The Simultaneist Defense of Retroactive Revaluation 7.3.4 Consistent Physicalist Valuation 7.4 The Law of Value and the Rate of Profit 7.4.1 The Constant-MELT Value/Price Rate of Profit 7.4.2 The Limited Influence of Inflation and a Rising MELT 7.4.3 A Rising-MELT Example 7.5 Recent Physicalist-Simultaneist Responses 7.5.1 The /Research in Political Economy /Symposia 7.5.2 Veneziani’s Critique 7.5.3 The Logical Status of the Okishio Theorem Notes Chapter 8 - The “Transformation Problem” (1): Marx’s Solution and Its Critics 8.1 Significance of the "Transformation Problem" and the Value-Price Relationship 8.2 Marx’s Resolution of the Classicists’ Problem 8.3 Böhm-Bawerk’s Critique 8.4 Postone’s Counter-Critique 8.5 Bortkiewicz’s Proof of Internal Contradiction 8.5.1 The Proof 8.5.2 The Refutation 8.6 Modern Simultaneist Critiques of Marx’s Solution Notes Chapter 9 - The “Transformation Problem” (2): If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Correct It 9.1 Bortkiewicz’s “Correction” 9.2 Theft vs. Honest Toil 9.3 The NI Solution 9.4 The SSSI Solution 9.5 The Temporal Single-System Interpretation 9.6 Critics’ Responses to the TSSI Appendix to Chapter 9: The Loranger and Moseley Solutions Loranger Moseley Notes Chapter 10 - The “Fundamental Marxian Theorem” 10.1 Introduction 10.2 The Corn Model 10.3 Intuitions Can Be Wrong 10.4 Failure of the Simultaneous Dual-System FMT 10.5 Reasonable Prices Can Differ 10.6 Failure of the NI-SSSI FMT 10.7 Surplus Labor and Profit under the TSSI 10.8 TSSI Results in the Negative-PNP Case 10.9 Conclusions Notes Chapter 11 - An Empirical Defense of the Law of Value? 11.1 Introduction 11.2 The Labor Theory of Price 11.3 The LTP and Marx’s Theory 11.4 The Spurious Correlation Problem 11.5 The Tautological Correlation Problem 11.6 The Measure of Size Matters 11.7 Data and Computations 11.8 Replication of Earlier Results 11.9 Controlling for the Influence of Industry Size 11.10 Regression Results 11.11 The (In)significance of Small Price-Value Deviations Notes Chapter 12 - Summary and Conclusions 12.1 General Summary and Main Results 12.2 Why Does the Myth of Inconsistency Persist? 12.3 The Task Ahead Notes Bibliography Index About the Author